Investor emotion alone
forecasts the stock market, averaging 27% per year for the last 50 years
with 1/2 the risk of the S&P500. Here's how:
You might ask; what kind of
proof exists, that emotions are so strong? If emotions come into
play we would expect that investors are feeling more optimistic after
the market closes up, verses a day the market closes down. Let's look at
the last 50 years of trading 1950-2000. If you had held the S&P500
index for the last 50 years, the return would have been 491%.
Now lets look at the day
after the market closed up and the day after the market closed down,
separately. We take the sum of the next day’s percentage change not
counting for dividends and commissions or compounding. Buying after up
days returned 875%. Buying on up days and selling short after down days
returned 1,265%. If you add in compounding, the holder (buy and hold) of
the S&P index would have gone from $100 in 1950 to $8,390 by October
2000. The emotional trader would have gone from $100 to $19,592,300. The
difference looks enormous but it is only a compound annual rate of 27.1%
verses the S&P500 50-year rate of 9.1%, about 3 to 1! If you
want to check this yourself, you can go to yahoo.com and download their
historical market data.
The worse loss for the long
term holder of the S&P index occurred in 1973-1974 with a drop of
over 48% and a recovery period of over 7 ½ years. The emotional
trader’s worse drop was about half (24.7%), it occurred in 1984 with a
recovery period of over 2 ½ years about 1/3 of that of the long-term
investor. It is interesting to note that the worse cases did not
coincide with each other indicating that some synergy may exist by
combining long-term investing and the right emotional based
program, see our investment
programs.
It is also important to
point out that trading in this particular manner, in that time period,
was impossible and this exercise, although theoretically correct, is
just to show that emotion has a large effect upon the stock market.
Emotional force isn't the only force acting upon the stock market, but
it is a strong force and should be recognized.
Our program utilizes the
power of the emotional element, but not in it's simplest form. We
might have a "buy" signal after a down day or a
"sell" signal after an up day. The raw emotional
element is only one part of the package.
|